What Should I Look for When Hiring an AEO/GEO Specialist?

If you run a small or medium-sized business selling products or services online, you’ve probably heard that AI is changing how people search. You may have noticed it yourself, using ChatGPT to compare products or asking Google a detailed question before choosing a service.

That might leave you wondering: should I hire a specialist? Can I do this myself? And how do I know who to trust?

Before investing, it helps to understand what an AEO/GEO specialist should do, what they will need from you and how their work can support your goals. Here’s what I recommend looking for.

1. Understand what an AEO/GEO specialist actually does

AEO stands for Answer Engine Optimisation, while GEO stands for Generative Engine Optimisation. You’ll often see these terms used to describe overlapping work: improving how your business appears in AI-generated answers and search experiences.

In practical terms, a specialist should investigate whether your website can be found, whether your content answers relevant customer questions and whether your business information is clear and accurate.

Their work might include:

  • Checking for technical issues that prevent relevant search and AI systems from accessing your pages.

  • Researching the topics, search terms and questions your customers explore before buying or making an enquiry.

  • Improving the structure and content of your product or service pages.

  • Identifying questions your website does not currently answer.

  • Reviewing how your business appears in AI answers and the sources those answers reference.

  • Setting up tracking to understand progress.

This is a collaborative process. Your consultant can research your market, but some information needs to come from you: what makes your service different, which questions customers ask and why they choose your business.

Be prepared to spend some time answering questions, sharing your expertise and reviewing content.

2. They should ask about your business before suggesting tactics

Pay attention to the questions a specialist asks during your first conversations. They should want to understand your business before recommending a plan.

Who are your customers? Which products or services do you want to grow? Where do you operate? What makes an enquiry valuable to you?

For example, you might run an online bike shop selling bikes and accessories, but your priority is to sell more electric bikes. That should influence the research, pages and content your consultant prioritises.

An increase in visits to an accessories blog might be useful, but you also need progress towards the products you want to sell.

A good specialist should be able to explain how their proposed work connects to your business priorities.

3. They should have a strong understanding of SEO

SEO and AI search work share many foundations, including accessible websites, useful content and clear information about your business.

My preference is to have someone who understands both and can build a connected strategy for your website.

When speaking with a potential consultant, ask about their SEO experience and how they have adapted their approach to AI search. Don’t assume that every SEO professional offers the same level of experience in this area.

Ask them to explain:

  • The challenges they have worked on.

  • What they changed and why.

  • The results they measured.

  • What they have learnt from projects involving AI search.

A useful case study should help you understand their decisions and contribution. A screenshot showing a business mentioned in ChatGPT gives you only a small part of the picture.

4. They should research what your customers ask before buying

Your consultant should investigate the questions people ask when deciding what to buy or which business to contact.

These questions often go beyond a product or service name. Customers might want to understand prices, compare options, check suitability or resolve a concern.

For a hotel, examples could include:

  • How far is the hotel from [local attraction], and how can I get there?

  • Does the hotel have parking, and is it included in the room rate?

  • Can two adults and two children stay in the same room?

  • Does the hotel cater for gluten-free or vegan breakfasts?

  • Can I cancel or change my booking if my plans change?

Clear answers help potential guests decide whether the hotel meets their needs and feel more confident about booking.

Ask your consultant how they will research these questions and decide which ones matter most. Useful starting points include search data, customer enquiries, sales conversations and competitor research.

They should also check whether existing pages can answer these questions better. Sometimes, improving a product or service page is a higher priority than publishing another blog.

5. They should explain what they will deliver

Before starting, make sure you understand what is included in the service.

Will the consultant update your website directly? Write content? Brief your developer? Or provide recommendations for your team to implement?

These details matter, especially if you have limited time or support.

You should receive a prioritised plan explaining what needs to happen, why it matters and who is responsible. Clarify whether development, content production or tracking tools involve additional costs.

I also recommend agreeing on regular progress calls. These give you time to review completed work, discuss results and adjust priorities when something changes in your business.

You should be able to understand what you are paying for and what happens next.

6. They should measure progress towards leads and sales

Website visits, AI mentions, citations and visits referred by AI platforms can all help you understand visibility. Tracking a relevant set of customer questions can also help identify opportunities.

But your reporting should connect this information to your business goals.

For an online shop, that might mean purchases and revenue. For a service business, it could mean qualified enquiries, booked consultations or quote requests.

Ask how the consultant will track these actions and establish a starting point before making changes.

There are limits to measurement. Someone might discover your business through an AI answer and return later through another channel, so you cannot attribute every sale precisely. Equally, more AI mentions do not automatically mean more customers.

A good consultant should explain what the data shows, where there is uncertainty and what they recommend doing next.

7. They should provide evidence and set realistic expectations

Ask for examples that relate to your goals. A specialist does not need to have worked with an identical business, but they should explain how their experience applies to yours.

When reviewing results, look for context. What was the starting point? Over what period did the improvement happen? What work did the consultant complete? Were other marketing activities happening at the same time?

They should also be honest about what they can control. They can improve your website, research opportunities and test changes, but they cannot guarantee that an AI platform will recommend your business.

Be cautious of promises of guaranteed placements, immediate sales or a fixed number of leads.

A credible proposal should explain the opportunities, the priorities and how progress will be reviewed.

Finally, can I do AEO/GEO myself, or do I need a specialist?

There are things you can do yourself, especially when it comes to content. As a business owner, you know your customers, the questions they ask and what makes them hesitate before buying or booking.

Start by reviewing your website. Does it clearly explain what you offer, who it is suitable for and what customers need to know before deciding? Answering questions about prices, what is included and how your service works is a useful starting point.

A specialist can take this further through deeper customer and competitor research, identifying questions you have overlooked and gaps in your content. They can also review your site structure, navigation and internal links to determine which pages need improving, where new pages would be useful and how to make your important products or services easier to find.

Technical SEO and AEO require additional knowledge, from checking whether search engines and relevant AI systems can access your content to implementing structured data that helps describe it. Learning how to identify and address these issues takes time, and some fixes may require a developer.

The value of a specialist is in turning these findings into a clear, prioritised plan that supports more enquiries or sales. Professional support also helps you keep pace as AI search evolves. Monitoring changes, assessing their relevance and adapting your strategy takes ongoing work, which can be difficult to manage alongside running your business.

Questions to ask before hiring an AEO/GEO specialist

You don’t need to understand every technical detail to make a good hiring decision. Start with these questions:

1. What would you prioritise for my business, and why?

2. How will this work support my existing SEO?

3. What will you deliver in the first three months?

4. Who will make the changes to my website? What will you need from my side?

5. How will we measure results?

6. Can you share a relevant example and explain your contribution?

7. What is included in the fee, and what costs extra?

8. Are calls included throughout the process?

Listen for clear explanations, relevant questions and a plan that fits your resources. You should leave the conversation understanding how the specialist intends to help your business and what they will need from you.

If you’re considering SEO and AI search support, get in touch to discuss your goals and where to focus first.

FAQs

How much does it cost to hire an AEO/GEO specialist?

The cost depends on your website’s size, the work required and the level of ongoing support. Ask for a clear breakdown of what is included, such as research, technical reviews, content updates and reporting. Check whether implementation, development or tracking tools cost extra so you can compare proposals fairly.

How long does AEO/GEO take to show results?

There is no fixed timeline. Your starting point, competition and how quickly recommendations are implemented all affect progress. Ask your specialist what they expect to achieve in the first three months, which early signs they will monitor and when you will review progress towards enquiries or sales.

Do I need to create new content for AEO/GEO?

Not always. Your existing product pages, service pages and blogs may already contain useful information but need clearer answers, updated details or better internal links. A specialist should review what you have before recommending new content, prioritising changes that help customers make decisions.

Is AEO/GEO worthwhile for a local business?

It can be, particularly when customers need help choosing a nearby service or place to visit. Clear information about your location, services, prices and availability helps people assess whether your business meets their needs. A specialist should first investigate relevant customer searches and opportunities to determine how AI search work fits alongside your local SEO priorities.